Monday, February 16, 2009

Dennewitz After Action Report

I ran the Dennewitz scenario for my wargaming club, The Northern Conspiracy, last Friday at our monthly game night. I've been preparing for the game since my original play test in my basement which I reported earlier in this blog. Since my last update I was able to finalize the terrain for the game by flocking the forest marker felts to match the table cloth from my previous post. I also took some time and put my laser engraver to use making some 'Barker Markers' for pre-measuring a massed stand's location as well as a ZOC and angle gauge. The angle gauge we affectionately called 'hockey sticks' for obvious reasons. They have a 45-degree angle to measure obliques and fire arc as well as a 1" wide base for frontal ZOC and 1/4" wide shaft for side ZOC measuring. These were made in 2/3 scale which is what we use for 15mm games. We call this the 'hinch' scale.

This scenario was run on the full map as provided in the Road to Glory scenario that starts on page 84 of the Volley and Bayonet rulebook. I use the order of arrival and the OBs from the scenario verbatim with one exception: I added the Swedish Mormer Hussars and horse battery which is reported to have been present at the battle (see the OB here: http://napoleonistyka.atspace.com/Battle_of_Dennewitz.htm

The opening moves for the French were comprised of a cautious advance to and deployment behind the Agger from the bridge, eastward to Rohrbeck by the Italian division with the French Cavalry guarding the left flank towards Gohldorf. The following few turns were comprised of each army deploying their arriving troops in parallel lines approximately 1400 yards from each other. The allies on a line from Dennewitz, through Gohldorf and extending approximately straight beyond Gohldorf. The French lines formed up southeast of the allies. During the deployment, artillery dueling between the artillery accompanying the Italians and the artillery of the Prussian Advanced guard division proved to be ineffective on both sides.

During the final stages of a lengthy and cautious deployment on both sides, von Oppen's Prussian cavalry division charged the extreme left flank of the deploying French force routing a brigade of French cavalry, only later to be repulsed and mostly destroyed by massed artillery and infantry small arms fire. Also on the right French flank, the Italians sortied out of Rohrbeck to try to out-flank the Prussian advanced guard. Recently-arrived reinforcements were able to repulse the Italians, driving them back through Rohrbeck and across the Agger. In the center, an opportunistic charge by the Prissuan Brandenburg Dragoons routed a French infantry brigade, but the French were able to reform their ranks in their following turn.

As dark approached the Prussian advanced guard began withdrawing behind the ridge between Dennewitz and Rohrbeck to avoid receiving additional casualties from the French artillery that had finally ranged in and begun to inflict casualties, but it was obvious to both teams that significant improvements in their positions could not be made before nightfall. The game was called by mutual agreement of both teams a turn before dark. The final point difference of .5 victory points was essentially a draw. Neither team made any mistakes and both teams played very cautiously which allowed for this outcome. I think this is a very well balance scenario that John Holtz has designed, and the players in my game very much wanted the additional time to play an additional day of battle. I hope to run the scenario again on one of our game days to allow them exactly that opportunity. Both armies had areas of strength and areas of weakness in their deployments and it would have been interesting to see how the battle would have played out if the players had time to conduct another day of battle.

Unfortunately for me I forgot my camera at home. I hope to augment this post with some photos that were taken by my friend Phil, as soon as I can get them from him.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Preparing for another Dennewitz

I've spent the majority of my hobby time the past couple of weeks preparing to host another Dennewitz game. This next one will be this upcoming Friday at my club's monthly game night. When possible I like to play test my scenarios at home before subjecting the club to them. This helps me work out any kinks in the scenario and get things balanced so the game is fun for both sides, even if this means tweaking the forces or arrival times a bit. The test run of this scenario (see my previous updates below) went well. The published scenario seemed well balanced and the decisions of the players in my first game dictated the outcome, which is my preference. Since I didn't have to work on the scenario, this gave me extra time to work on other aspects of the game, starting with the pictured dedicated terrain cloth. I expect that I will be running this game a few times so I took the time to flock a felt with all the roads in place for the battle. This makes a much nicer looking tabletop but still allows be to set up the game rapidly at location away from my home.

One of the things that we as wargamers have to deal with in our games is distortion of scale. Figure scale, ground scale, time scale are all balanced to try to give a good playable game while maintaining as much historic accuracy as possible. Most gamers try to match the scale of their buildings to the figure height scale, i.e. 15mm buildings with 15mm figures. In the past I have also done this. Recently my uncle Ralph has been using 6mm buildings to represent towns in his 15mm V&B games under the assumption that these more accurately match the ground scale and have the benefit of not making towns and villages occupy an unreasonably large amount of the tabletop. Considering that Dennewitz has eight (8) towns on it's small tabletop I found that this necessitated that I adopt Ralph's philosophy and build up eight town blocks using 6mm terrain. I chose to buy my buildings from Timecast Models from the UK. I chose them because they had a good selection of Eastern European models suitable for Napoleonic battles. The top photo here shows a close-up of one of my town blocks using Timecast's walls and buildings. The buildings are removable for when the town is occupied by a stand of troops. This allows the town to occupy a minimal footprint on the game table. The photo to the right shows a wider-angle view of a couple of the towns bracing the marshy-banked river that is a central feature of the battlefield. The 6mm bridge is also a Timecast model.

I was still missing a couple of stands of Dragoons mounted on linear stands, so I also painted them up. Per the recommendations of the members of the Volley & Bayonet Yahoo group I added a light wash (made by diluting my 25mm wash) to emphasize the details of the figures. I was a bit gun-shy about using the full strength wash in fear that it would muddy the figures too much, but in the end I think I swayed the other way a bit too much and could probably have diluted it less for a stronger effect. Still it's an improvement over the non-washed figures. It also shows up a bit more in person than in photographs under incandescent light.

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Landwehr Cavalry for Dennewitz

After hosting Dennewitz at my house and enjoying the scenario, I decided that I should bring the game to my club's game night in February. In order to do so I thought it would be best to try to paint up the figures that I borrowed from my friend Ed to run the first game. The Prussians have a very interesting organization in this battle. Each infantry brigade (as the Prussians call it, functionally they're the same as other army's divisions) contains three regiments of infantry including some light infantry skirmishers, a battalion of artillery, and a small regiment of cavalry. These small regiments are based in Volley & Bayonet on linear cavalry stands - something that is fairly uncommon, so I needed to paint up figures specifically for this purpose. I also didn't have any massed Landwehr cavalry yet and the scenario requires a unit of that as well. While I had the figures on the table I also painted up a mounted Landwehr officer to represent General von Lindenau, commander of the Prussian advanced guard division. Since the advanced guard division is comprised almost entirely of Landwehr, I thought an officer in a Landwehr uniform was called for.

The figures are AB miniatures. I hadn't used AB before, but they make Prussian reserve infantry in uniforms that I like, so when ordering up some of the reserve infantry figures I added in the cavalry figures I needed. The castings from AB are crisp, similar to Essex, only they're larger, about half way between Essex and Old Glory for size. I'm still quite a bit rusty painting 15mm figures, so these were painted using the same quick painting techniques I used on my Saxons. They're solid 'wargaming quality' paint jobs though - good enough for my table top games.



Saturday, January 10, 2009

Dennewitz & My New Saxons

My friend George has recently revived an old tradition in our club - members hosting games on at their homes on Friday nights between club events (which are hosted at a rented hotel function room). We used to do this quite often, in fact the club held ALL of its events in people's basements for over a decade before we got big enough to warrant renting a neutral location montly. This past Friday I decided to take my turn and host a 15mm Napoleonic Volley & Bayonet game. Since I haven't hosted a Napoleonic game using the new V&B rules I chose one of the scenarios from the rulebook - Dennewitz. I liked that it utilized my new Prussian figures that I purchased from GAJO as well as my Italian and Russian figures.

The game went well and I learned a lot about the scenario hosting it for the first time. This scenario has a lot of figures in a rather small space, so maneuver takes a second priority to lines of retreat and secure flanks. Both of the latter ended up being key to the battle. The initial deployments are shown above, for those familiar with the scenario I substituted Russian figures for some of the Prussians, specifically the advanced Armeekrops which deploys on the table. I used my Oplechene figures for the Landwher and kept all the ratings, etc. the same. I chose to use the small battlefield option, but in future games I will probably use the larger battlefield, at least the additional foot of terrain on the eastern side of the battlefield. If you're looking at the tabletop and things look small, we use 2/3 scale V&B stands and rulers to allow us to fight larger battles on standard size tables.

On turn one the French immediately occupied Dennewitz, but surprisingly were pushed right back out in the Allied half of turn one by the Russian Olplechne. The marshy stream on the south side of Dennewitz made subsequent assaults on Dennewitz too difficult and the French chose instead to roll up their heavy artillery battalions and set in for a siege of the town via artillery fire from the neighboring hillside.


On the left flank, initial Russian cavalry units on the battlefield met the advancing French troops outside of Goehlsdorf. When I was reading the order of arrival for the battle and the objectives I didn't anticipate the battle lines ending up running through Goehlsdorf, but that's indeed how it developed in our game. In the next few turns both sides deployed their arriving troops along the battle line running from Dennewitz to Goehlsdorf. During the confusion of this deployment, one regiment of Prussian dragoons (a linear V&B stand) chose a target of opportunity, and charged the heavy artillery battalions that were shelling Dennewitz in the flank. A successfull melee on the first battalion was followed up by a breakthrough charge on a second battery routing both. The following turn the French countercharged the blown Prussian dragoons and annhilited them, but the Prussian players thought that one regiment of dragoons was a fair trade for two battalions of heavy artillery. Other than this exchange the next few turns consisted of scattered long-range artillery fire and further deployment of the arriving armies.

On turn five the fighting began in earnest and also came to an instant climax when a combined Saxon and Italian charge on the Prussian center faltered and resulted in the Saxon and Italian troops falling back through their own reinforcing line disordering it. The following Prussian countercharge was sucessful across the line (with the exception of one stubborn Saxon artillery battalion that held its ground firmly) in routing the repulsed Italians and Saxons en masse opening up a huge gap in the French center. The photo to the left was taken part way through the resolution of the combat on the Prussian turn.

West of Goehlsdorf, theFrench cavalry which had just arrived deployed to guard the French left flank and help support the troops occupying the town. The Russian reserve cavalry was marching to the area and Phil hoped to bottle them up before they could deploy.


The final turn saw French counter charges across the board, but the Prussians held firmly even though the constant fighting had prevented them the opportunity to go stationary. With the primary victory conditions being exhaustion of enemy divisions the Allies were clear winners with no exhausted divisions and they held the Windmill heights for a total score of -1 for the French. The French had 3 divisions exhausted (including one collapsed). The result of the battle a solid Allied victory.


This was a fun game to host. I'd like to thank everyone who came and played, especially Phil who didn't get troops onto the board until late in the game due to my unfamiliarity with the order of arrival of the troops (sorry Phil). I'd also like to specially thank my friend Ed for lending me the Prussian cavalry based on linear stands which I needed for the game.


My New Saxons
(or how to paint a corps in a weekend)


When I decided to host Dennewitz, I scanned the OB and thought to myself, 'Wow, I have everything I need for this!' Then the day I sent out the invitatinos for the game I realized that there was one glaring exception to my assumption. I didn't have any Saxons....and there's a whole CORPS of them in this OB. Lucky for me I had the weekend free and the Saxons used French uniforms so I happened to have some unpainted figures that would be appropriate in my 'dead lead' box. I decided to try my hand at some 'speed painting' using a black primer technique and see if I could paint up a few units. The flags are from warflag.com printed on plain paper. There are two figure conversions in these units, but until I can get better close-up photos I'm going to leave them a secret.

To my surprise by Saturday evening I had painted up two brigades of infantry and four mounted Generals. Sunday I only had part of the day to paint but I was able to finish the artillerists, and artillery for four battalions of artillery, a brigade of cheveauleger cavalry as well as getting a start on the final two brigades of infantry. Monday night I was able to finish up the last of the infantry and base everything up. They won't win any contests, but I got it all done and still had plenty of time to set up the tabletop and label the troops for the game the following weekend.



Sorry for the poor quality photos, it's very windy here in New Hampshire in the winter and frightfully cold. Setting up my photo setup outside to get proper light is nigh impossible unless we get a very rare warm day, and I really wanted to include the Saxons in this post since I painted them for the battle.

Monday, January 5, 2009

33rd Foot

This is the most recent AWI unit I've completed. This was finished during a week-long power outage last month caused by an ice storm that devastated New England and in particular New Hampshire where I live. Being a hearty New Englander my house is equipped with a generator for emergency use. It powers our furnace, water pump, refrigerators and a few essential lights. With some clever routing of extension cords I was able to get a single lamp running in my painting room, just enough light to give me something to do in between refueling the generator. The unit was completed during the power outtage, along with two batteries which I'll be posting later. I waited until now to post them because I was waiting for the flags to arrive for it.

This is my version of the 33rd foot. I was inspired by Giles Allison's version of this unit which he posted in his blog, particularly when he listed all of the battles the 33rd foot fought in. Many of the battles the 33rd fought in are battles I like to fight on the tabletop. I've chosen to outfit my unit in tricornes, although I'm sure Giles' figure choice is more accurate. These were figures I had on hand when the power went 'poof' and I was desparate to get painting. Like all of my AWI figures, this unit is based for Volley & Bayonet rules as a two battalion unit with an additional skirmisher stand. Depending on the scale of the battle I choose to use this unit in it can represent itself in several scales, or at the highest scale each of the formed stands can represent a regiment (meaning one of the stands could represent the 53rd or 59th line).

The flag for this unit is my first from http://www.flagdude.com/. Rick O'Brien there was very helpful in fulfilling my special request of slightly smaller flags to fit the flag staffs I had already affixed to the figures. Although Rick's flags in full size are spectacular, I'm very happy with the high quality of workmanship he was able to achieve even at this smaller size. I ordered a few more flags in this order that will find their way onto other units soon. If you haven't seen any of Rick's flags, do yourself a favor and visit his site.

Friday, December 26, 2008

Shameless Plug

I paint a lot of the figures that I use in my wargames, but I'm also not afraid to buy figures when I can get ones painted as well or better than I can paint myself. The figures shown here are examples of the latter. They're one of the five units of French Young Guard that I'm listing for sale on Ebay (see my auctions here: http://search.ebay.com/_W0QQfgtpZ1QQfrppZ25QQsassZpease1

I purchased these figures a couple of years ago at Historicon in the flea market area. They're very nicely painted figures from I believe Battle Honors or Old Glory.

The reason I'm selling them is after basing up my French Army for Volley & Bayonet, I found that I had far too many Young Guard. These units are what remains after basing up both Young Guard corps for V&B. One of the big selling points for V&B for me is the low figure count necessary to field large armies. I purchased these figures when we were still using Napoleon's Battles which requires far more figures to represent the same units.

So, please visit my auctions, or send the links to interested friends. I'd love to find these figures a good home and turn the money earned by selling them back into other wargaming projects.

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

Kingsbridge - Covered Bridge

When my friend James and I decided to start doing projects for each other, the this is the first piece I asked him to make for me. Considering all of the covered bridges in New England, New York and Pennsylvania during the revolution and the American Civil War, I thought having a covered bridge for skirmish gaming and as a focal piece for larger battles would be great. The first use I had in mind was as the center piece for an AWI skirmish or V&B wing scale game using the forces that skirmished near Kingsbridge during the battle of White Plains. You can just make out the bridge in this photo when I ran this game at the first Tricon convention.

The bridge was masterfully built by James modeled after a covered bridge that still stands a short distance from his home in Vermont. The bridge accommodates 25mm figures nicely as shown in the photos. The roof, walls and even the deck are removable to allow access to the figures inside, or to simulate the destruction of the bridge by removing it and replacing it with some rubble. The river features sand shores, real rocks and water made from liquid latex artist's medium hand colored with powdered pigments. The roof is shingled by hand with individual wooden shingles.










Thursday, December 11, 2008

Small Breastworks - British Skirmishers

This is another of the terrain pieces my friend James made me a few years ago. This one was designed to hold a single unit of infantry based for The British are Coming! (TBAC) rules. We played TBAC for several years, but for the past few years have been playing Volley & Bayonet exclusively. We played a modified (house rules) version of TBAC which converted it to a turn, counter-turn system instead of the simultaneous movement system that it was designed to use. We found it worked more smoothly than the original design. In the end switching to V&B seemed the natural thing to do as our club has basically standardized V&B for all black powder periods. Having one set of rules for multiple periods means we don't have to teach the rules each game and we can get right to playing. Besting your opponent more often comes down to better battlefield decisions rather than a superior expertise in the rules. The V&B figure basing is slightly different than The British are Coming! but this terrain piece still seems to work nicely.

The British skirmishers are three stands I completed recently in order to prepare for a Brandywine Creek game I wanted to run. I needed to represent several small battalions, so I needed some extra skirmish stands. Knowing that this circumstance would occur often, I painted these three stands very genericly so that they can be used whenever I need such units. They're Old Glory figures from their 'British Firing Line' pack. I like this set of poses a lot and I've used several of these packs of figures to sprinkle throughout my other units to give the units a look of being in action instead of at parade rest. The rocks on the stands are small pieces of broken cork primed black and dry-brushed gray. They don't add much weight to the stand and fill the stand nicely giving the skirmishers some terrain to hide behind.

Saturday, December 6, 2008

V&B Road to Glory Rules Question

This is just a quick post about a rules question I'm going to be asking on the V&B mailing list. Since Yahoo Groups doesn't allow picture attachments to the e-mails sent to the mailing list, and I'm not savvy about posting to the Yahoo groups files section, I thought I'd just post my photo here and ask the question on the list and point the list membership here to view the photos. The figures are some random V&B stands from my French and Italian Napoleonic armies. I used them for this photo because they were handy.

My question revolves around the changes that are a result of the last sentence of rule 10.3.2 Advances After Combat which reads, "A victorious unit may not advnace to contact an enemy unit, and must stop a quarter inch away from it." add to the new version of the rules. In the situation where two lines of troops meet and one unit loses a melee and retreats (see photo above), our intrepretation of the first edition of the rules was that unit B above would be allowed to occupy position X vacated by unit 2. According to the new rule, this would be prohibited by the 1/4" non-advance zone shown from the neighboring units (see below). My question is simply is this an intended outcome, or was the 1/4" prohibition only intended to apply to the front face of enemy units?


Update, December 8th: For the curious, here's the answer I got from Frank Chadwick, the author of V&B: "Correct. It was actually never my intention that stands be able to advance into contact after melee, but that was not clear from the 1st edition rules. -- Frank" It's great to have such a quick and concise response from the rules author. Thanks Frank!

Thursday, December 4, 2008

Queens Loyal Rangers and Redoubt

Giles over at Tarleton's Quarter recently posted some photos of some of his excellent terrain pieces and that reminded me that I should do the same over here on my blog. This is the first of such posts. I'm also showing some figures I painted up a while ago that get a lot of use in my games, my Queen's Loyal Rangers.

The redoubt was scratch built by my friend James Gibbons in trade for some modeling work I did for him. We had a good system of exchanging time for time equally trading specialties. I received some excellent terrain like this redoubt, James received several 1/72 scale WWI aircraft models to use in his wargames. It was a great trade. The redoubt is sized for 25mm figures and features a firing step, and also an artillery embrasure with removeable gun platform.

The Queen's Loyal Rangers unit has both a formed stand, as well as two separate skirmish stands. Like most of my AWI figures, depending on the scale I use for my V&B games, the stands can represent the Queen's Rangers in all V&B scales by using a single skirmish stand, two skirmish stands, the formed stand, or all three stands. A lot of my close-up photos don't show my painting style in the best light as I use heavy highlights and washes to give a good tabletop look. The photo below of the Rangers in the redoubt gives a better impression of how this look works on the tabletop.